[Swayam Mundhra is a fifth-year student at Gujarat National Law University, and Moksha Pancholi is a fifth-year student at Jindal Global Law School]
On 26 October 2026, in Bank of India v S.M. Kamal Pasha (Kamal Pasha), the Supreme Court answered a question the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016 (IBC) never addresses. Can a committee of creditors (CoC) walk away from a resolution plan it has already approved, while that plan is still awaiting approval from the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT)? The Court said it cannot. In the insolvency of TD Toll Road Private Limited (TD Toll Road), the plan had sat before the NCLT for over four years, and in that time the company built up cash almost equal to what the bidder had offered for it.
This post accepts that, after Kamal Pasha, a CoC cannot act alone, but argues that the law should allow the NCLT, not the CoC, to permit withdrawal where the company’s value has changed materially for unforeseeable reasons, with the bidder compensated.
The TD Toll Road Dispute
TD Toll Road was admitted into the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) on 25 November 2019. On 7 May 2021, the CoC unanimously approved a plan of about ₹172.5 crore submitted by the successful resolution applicant (SRA), who then furnished a performance bank guarantee of about ₹8.62 crore. The resolution professional filed the plan for approval before the NCLT on 29 June 2021.
The approval process then stalled. The suspended management challenged the admission order, and the Supreme Court stayed the proceedings in January 2022, dismissing the challenge only on 9 December 2024. By 2025, the company had built up a substantial cash reserve: before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), the resolution professional put it at over ₹120 crore and the CoC at about ₹165 crore, against a plan value of ₹172.5 crore. On 2 December 2025, the CoC resolved to withdraw the plan and invite fresh bids, and on 8 December 2025 the NCLT allowed the withdrawal on an oral request.
On 20 April 2026, the NCLAT set that order aside in S.M. Kamal Pasha v S. Rajendran, Resolution Professional of TD Toll Road Private Limited. Its holding was blunt: “The CoC has no jurisdiction to take any decision to withdraw the resolution plan.” The creditors appealed to the Supreme Court.
The Law and the Supreme Court’s Ruling
The IBC itself is silent on whether a CoC can withdraw an approved plan. Section 30(4) requires a plan to be approved by at least 66% of the voting share of the CoC, and section 31(1) requires the NCLT to approve it if it meets the requirements of section 30(2).
The NCLAT relied on the Explanation to regulation 18(2) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) Regulations 2016, which permits CoC meetings until the plan is approved under section 31(1), but only to “decide on matters which do not affect the resolution plan submitted before the Adjudicating Authority.”
It also relied on two Supreme Court decisions. In Ebix Singapore Private Limited v Committee of Creditors of Educomp Solutions Limited (Ebix), the Court held that a submitted plan is “binding and irrevocable as between the CoC and the successful Resolution Applicant“. In State Bank of India v Consortium of Murari Lal Jalan and Florian Fritsch (Jalan), it said that once a plan is submitted, “it immediately becomes binding on the CoC and the SRA, even if the adjudicating authority has not yet given its stamp of approval on the same.” In Express Resorts and Hotels Limited v Amit Jain (Express Resorts), the NCLAT had refused to let a CoC reopen an approved plan because higher offers had arrived after the pandemic.
Under section 12A, 90% of the CoC could once withdraw the entire CIRP, and an approved plan would fall with it. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act 2026 (2026 Amendment) now bars such withdrawal once the first invitation for resolution plans has been issued.
The Supreme Court closed whatever room remained. It held that the Ebix “dictum applies squarely to the CoC too“, and, reading section 12A with sections 30(2) and 31, that once the plan is before the NCLT “there can be no withdrawal either of the application or the approved Resolution Plan“. The Court accepted that long delays in approval affect implementation, and noted that the delay here arose from its own stay. The only check left is the NCLT’s review under section 30(2), where it must verify the company’s present finances, but “improved profitability alone cannot be a reason to refuse approval“. Whether the bidder keeps the windfall was left to the NCLT, on observations the Court called prima facie.
The Competing Arguments
The bidder’s case, which the Court accepted, is not a weak one. In Ebix, the bidder was held to its plan even though it argued that Educomp had changed a great deal after approval, and future bidders will bid lower if an approved plan can be unpicked once the numbers look better.
The creditors’ case rests on delay, which neither side controls. The IBC expects a CIRP to finish within 330 days. In AVJ Heightss Apartment Owners Association v IIFL Finance Limited, the Supreme Court took suo motu cognizance of 363 plan approval applications pending before the NCLT, with delays of up to 738 days and in some cases four years, and described the picture as “dismal“.
In Kamal Pasha, the plan waited over four years for reasons that had nothing to do with the creditors. Holding them to the 2021 price does not respect their commercial wisdom, because the company they valued in 2021 is not the company that exists today.
At the same time, the CoC in Kamal Pasha decided to withdraw with only about 74% of the vote. If a vote of that kind were enough, no SRA could treat an approval as final. The NCLT, not the CoC, should decide.
A Way Forward: Let the NCLT Decide
In the United Kingdom, a scheme of arrangement under Part 26 of the Companies Act 2006, or a restructuring plan under Part 26A, does not bind anyone merely because creditors have voted for it; the court must sanction it, and may refuse. The Practice Statement on these Parts requires that any material change in circumstances after the convening hearing be brought to the attention of the court or the creditors. Creditors in England therefore cannot withdraw a plan by a fresh vote, but the court is also not obliged to sanction a plan whose basis has changed.
In the United States, rule 3018(a) of the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure permits a creditor to change or withdraw its acceptance of a Chapter 11 plan only “for cause shown”, after notice and a hearing.
After Kamal Pasha, a similar model under the IBC can only come from Parliament. A CoC that wants to withdraw an approved plan should have to file a written application before the NCLT, supported by at least 66% of the voting share (the threshold under section 30(4)). The oral request the NCLT accepted on 8 December 2025 would not qualify.
The NCLT would then examine whether the value of the corporate debtor has changed materially after approval for reasons that could not have been foreseen when the CoC voted. In Kamal Pasha, nobody in May 2021 could have predicted that the company would hold between ₹120 crore and ₹165 crore in cash by 2025. A higher bid alone would not suffice, consistent with Express Resorts.
If withdrawal is allowed, the SRA should be compensated. Its performance bank guarantee of ₹8.62 crore would be released, it would be reimbursed for its documented costs and paid a reasonable break fee, and it would have the right to match the highest fresh bid. A bidder that recovers its costs and can match any later offer has little reason to price in the risk of withdrawal. A 30-day limit for deciding the application would stop the remedy itself from adding to the delay.
This can be done by adding a proviso to section 31, with the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India amending the Explanation to regulation 18(2) to match. The Court in Ebix itself said that whether changes after submission should be permitted is a matter of “legislative policy“.
Conclusion
Kamal Pasha protects bidders for good reason. But it makes a CoC’s vote irrevocable however long approval takes, and places the entire cost of judicial delay on creditors who caused none of it. With the 2026 Amendment closing the section 12A route, that rule now has no safety valve. Parliament must now decide whether the NCLT should be able to permit withdrawal in a rare case like this one, and on what conditions.
– Swayam Mundhra & Moksha Pancholi