SUPREME COURT CLARIFIES THE LIMITS OF HIGH COURT’S SUPERVISORY JURISDICTION AND RIGHT OF IMPLEADMENT IN SECTION 92 CPC SUIT

INTRODUCTION

In Subhasindu Das & Ors. v. Bacchu Ranjan Das & Ors., 2026 INSC 1250, decided on 19 November 2026 by a Bench comprising Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh, the Supreme Court examined the scope of the High Court’s supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution and the right of individuals to seek impleadment in representative suits under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC).

The Court reiterated that Article 227 cannot be exercised as an appellate jurisdiction and that the representative nature of a suit does not automatically entitle every member or devotee of an institution to become a party.

BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE

The dispute concerned the administration and management of Sri Guru Sangha, a charitable society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. The Appellants, who were members of the Sangha, had instituted a Suit under Section 92 CPC seeking, among other reliefs, removal of certain Office Bearers and framing of a management scheme.

During the pendency of the Suit, the Trial Court appointed Smt. Banani Ghosh as Special Officer. Following allegations of irregularities, the Trial Court called for her explanation and, after considering it, removed her on 7 June 2022. It also constituted a 13-member ad hoc committee to manage the Sangha, subject to quarterly reporting and annual audits.

The Calcutta High Court stayed the operation of this Order. In separate proceedings, the Trial Court also rejected Applications filed by Bachhu Ranjan Das and Bablu Das seeking impleadment in the Suit, holding that their general allegations of mismanagement and association with the Sangha were insufficient. The High Court subsequently set aside that rejection and permitted fresh applications.

The Appellants challenged these Orders before the Supreme Court.

ISSUES OF LAW

The principal issues before the Court were:

  • Whether the High Court was justified in interfering with the Trial Court’s interim management arrangements under Article 227 of the Constitution.
  • Whether a Suit under Section 92 CPC automatically entitles every member or devotee of the institution to be impleaded.
  • Whether the High Court could set aside a reasoned order rejecting impleadment without identifying any legal infirmity or perversity.

ANALYSIS OF THE JUDGMENT

The Supreme Court observed that the Trial Court was competent to make interim arrangements for the proper administration and protection of the Sangha during the pendency of the Suit. The appointment of a Special Officer did not confer any vested right to continue in that position. Since the Trial Court had called for and considered Smt. Banani Ghosh’s written explanation before removing her, the High Court’s assumption that she had been denied an opportunity of hearing was not supported by the record.

On the scope of Article 227, the Court relied upon M/s Garment Craft v. Prakash Chand Goel, (2022) 4 SCC 181. It reiterated that supervisory jurisdiction is not intended to correct every factual or legal error or to substitute the High Court’s conclusions for those of the subordinate court. Interference is justified in cases of patent jurisdictional error, perversity or grave miscarriage of justice. Finding no such infirmity, the Supreme Court held that the High Court’s interference with the Trial Court’s interim arrangement was unwarranted.

The Court also examined Order I Rule 10(2) CPC, which empowers the court to add a party whose presence is necessary or proper for the effective and complete adjudication of the dispute.

It clarified that although a suit under Section 92 CPC is representative in nature, this does not give every member or devotee an automatic right to participate as a party. An applicant must demonstrate sufficient grounds and explain how their presence is necessary or proper for deciding the issues involved. General allegations of collusion or mismanagement, without supporting particulars, are not sufficient.

The Supreme Court found that the High Court had set aside the Trial Court’s Order principally because the Suit was representative in nature and other persons could be affected by its outcome. That consideration alone could not dispense with the requirements of Order I Rule 10(2) CPC.

The Court accordingly restored the Trial Court’s Orders. It also declined to appoint a fresh committee or independent administrator, observing that subsequent allegations of financial and administrative irregularities involved disputed questions which could be examined by the Trial Court.

Importantly, the Supreme Court clarified that it had not expressed any final opinion on the merits of the underlying Suit or the allegations concerning the Sangha’s administration.

SARTHAK KALRA

Senior Legal Associate

The Indian Lawyer & Allied Services

EDITOR’S COMMENTS

The Judgment reinforces two important principles of civil procedure. First, the High Court’s supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 must be exercised within established limits and cannot be used merely to substitute its view for that of the Trial Court. Second, the representative nature of a suit under Section 92 CPC does not create an automatic right of impleadment; the requirements of Order I Rule 10(2) CPC must still be satisfied.

The decision also recognises the Trial Court’s authority to make appropriate interim arrangements for the protection and administration of charitable institutions while the substantive disputes remain pending.

SUSHILA RAM VARMA

Advocate & Chief Consultant

The Indian Lawyer & Allied Services

Please log onto our YouTube channel, The Indian Lawyer Legal Tips, to learn about various aspects of the law. Our latest Video, titled “Can Adoptive Mothers Take Maternity Leave? Shocking Truth!” can be viewed at the link below:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZqgGRVZkr4g

Read More