
INTRODUCTION
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India recently resolved a long-standing, multi-tiered dispute concerning thousands of plot Allottees affected by regulatory action against Pearls Agrotech Corporation Limited (hereinafter PACL). In Subrata Bhattacharya v. Securities and Exchange Board of India & Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 13301 of 2015 with Civil Appeal No. 13394 of 2015), decided on November 19, 2026, a Two-Judge Bench comprising Hon’ble Justices Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Atul S. Chandurkar delivered a comprehensive Order disposing of Interlocutory Applications (IAs) filed by Allottees of Residential Projects at Sectors 100 and 104 in Mohali, as well as Bathinda. The Hon’ble Court established a definitive five-tier framework to categorize Allottees based on verifiable payment modes and timelines, balancing equitable restitution for legitimate purchasers with the mandate to bring decade-long liquidation proceedings to a firm conclusion.
BRIEF FACTS
- At the heart of the dispute was the regulatory action initiated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) against PACL in 1999, directing the Company to wind up its operations or register as a Collective Investment Scheme (CIS).
- PACL challenged SEBI’s Notices before the High Court of Rajasthan, which quashed the Notices in 2003; however, the Supreme Court set aside that ruling in 2013 and remanded the matter back to SEBI for de novo
- Upon remand, SEBI concluded that PACL was operating an unregistered CIS and directed the refund of investor funds, a decision subsequently affirmed by the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT).
- In ongoing appeals against the SAT Order, the Supreme Court constituted the Justice (Retd.) R.M. Lodha Committee on February 2, 2016, tasking it with liquidating PACL’s land assets and facilitating equitable refunds.
- The Committee scrutinized claims concerning Residential Units across Sectors 100 and 104 in Mohali (comprising 2,032 units) and Bathinda (comprising 1,078 units).
- Following extensive audits by chartered accountants engaged by the Committee, the Committee submitted a report dated April 19, 2025, proposing a five-category scheme which was later collated in an Amicus Note dated October 8, 2026, submitted by learned Amici Curiae Mr. Ranjit Kumar and Mr. Shadan Farasat.
ISSUES OF LAW
The Apex Court primarily locked its focus onto two pivotal questions:
- Whether Allottees of a Company undergoing liquidation under extraordinary judicial supervision can be categorized for relief (issuance of sale certificates/NOCs versus cash refunds) based strictly on verified banking transaction records and payment cut-off dates.
- Whether the Supreme Court, while exercising extraordinary jurisdiction to secure investor restitution, should entertain requests to convert summary liquidation proceedings into individual suits for specific performance or grant relief for unverified cash payments.
ANALYSIS OF THE JUDGMENT
Adopting a pragmatic and realistic stance to conclude a decade of complex litigation, the Supreme Court laid down several clear observations and directions:
- Acceptance of the Five-Category Framework: The Court formally adopted the Committee’s five-tier classification based on bank audits:
- Category I: Allottees who made full payment via banking channels (RTGS/cheque) with or without possession/sale deeds. These plots are treated as sold and Recovery Officers under Section 28A of the SEBI Act are directed to issue sale certificates/NOCs and possession certificates within 8 weeks.
- Category II: Allottees who made over 50% part-payment via banking channels. These allotments are treated as sold; Allottees must pay the audited outstanding balance and internal development contributions within 30 days of receiving a balance statement to receive their sale certificates/NOCs. Failure to pay results in treatment as unsold inventory subject to refund.
- Category III: Allottees who made less than 50% part-payment via banking channels. The units are treated as unsold and the audited amounts paid will be refunded with 8% interest per annum within 3 months of a successful plot auction.
- Category IV: Unverified cash payments (full/part) or payments made via banking channels after the freezing date of February 2, 2016.
- Category V: Allottees who transferred their allotment during the pendency of proceedings, who will be governed by the specific rules of Categories I to IV applicable to their original transaction.
- Rejection of Specific Performance Claims: The Court firmly rejected prayers by Category III Allottees seeking options to pay remaining balances at current circle/market rates or requesting partial land transfers. The Bench emphasized that its primary mandate is securing reasonable restitution for investors rather than converting these proceedings into suits for specific performance.
- Treatment of Post-Cutoff Banking Payments: Applicants in Category IV who made payments via banking channels after the cut-off date of February 2, 2016, were granted parity with Category III Allottees, entitling them to an 8% per annum interest refund on audited payments following an auction.
- Clarification on Civil Remedies for Cash Allottees: Regarding Category IV applicants claiming unverified cash payments, the Court held that while the Lodha Committee will not process cash refunds or allotments, these allottees are not barred from filing civil suits for recovery/declaration against PACL. The Court clarified that the injunction granted on May 2, 2016, only protects statutory and monitoring bodies (SEBI and the Lodha Committee) from being impleaded, without barring substantive suits against the company itself.
ANIKET KUMAR PARCHA
Legal Associate
The Indian Lawyer & Allied Services
EDITOR’S COMMENTS
Finding that prolonged proceedings cannot hazard uncertain commercial remedies, the Hon’ble Supreme Court provided clear procedural finality to the affected Allottees. Consequently, the Apex Court issued detailed operational directions for each category, directed the Committee to verify specific Category I inclusion applications and disposed of the Interlocutory Applications. This Jugdement sends a powerful message regarding public interest litigation and financial restructuring: extraordinary summary jurisdiction exercised for public restitution must prioritize timely, audited and realistic financial returns over endless litigation and speculative property transfers.
SUSHILA RAM VARMA
Advocate & Chief Consultant
The Indian Lawyer & Allied Services
Please log onto our YouTube channel, The Indian Lawyer Legal Tips, to learn about various aspects of the law. Our latest Video, titled “Can Adoptive Mothers Take Maternity Leave? Shocking Truth!” can be viewed at the link below:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZqgGRVZkr4g