SpicyIP Weekly Review (November 09-November 15)

Image with SpicyIP logo and the words "Weekly Review"

After a busy week featuring several interesting and important posts on some pressing questions in Indian IP law and policy, we are back to kick off the week with another edition of the SpicyIP Weekly Review. This Weekly Review brings together discussions on a range of issues, from the proposed introduction of data exclusivity and its implications for India’s pharmaceutical landscape to the limits of territorial jurisdiction in IP disputes and the evolving contours of personality rights. Anything we are missing out on? Drop a comment below and let us know.

Highlights of the Week

[Part I] The Trial of Data Exclusivity

With reports suggesting that the Organization of Pharmaceutical Products in India is pushing for up to 10–12 years of data exclusivity protection in India, the debate over affordable medicines and pharmaceutical innovation is once again gaining momentum. But what would such a regime mean for India’s carefully negotiated patent bargain, generic competition, and access to medicines? In Part I of the three-part post, Arnav Kaman examines the parallels between patent protection and data exclusivity, and the important questions that the proposed framework raises.

[Part II] The Trial of Data Exclusivity

Continuing the discussion on the proposed introduction of data exclusivity in India, in Part II of his three-part post, Arnav Kaman examines its potential implications for domestic innovation, access to medicines, foreign investment, and the conduct of clinical trials. He also questions whether data exclusivity would address the underlying challenges facing India’s clinical trial ecosystem, and whether the promised benefits would justify the costs to public health and the domestic pharmaceutical industry.

[Part III] The Trial of Data Exclusivity

In the third part of the post on data exclusivity, Arnav Kaman explores whether there are alternative ways to incentivise domestic pharmaceutical innovation and clinical trials without introducing a data exclusivity regime. In this post, he examines possible policy interventions and alternative models, including a compensatory liability framework, while also highlighting the need for meaningful public consultation before any such policy decisions are made.

[Part I] How Much is Too Much? Looking at ABD Maestro v Great Galleon Ventures

Delhi continues to be a preferred destination for IP litigation, but how far can plaintiffs stretch territorial jurisdiction to bring their disputes before the DHC? In a decision returning 17 IP plaints for want of territorial jurisdiction, the DHC lays down a detailed account of when and how jurisdiction can be invoked. In this two part post, Maneesha Gupta looks at the DHC’s reasoning on composite suits, carrying on business, cause of action, and investigator-led trap purchases.

[Part II] How Much is Too Much? Looking at ABD Maestro v Great Galleon Ventures

Picking up from Part I, in Part II of her post, Maneesha Gupta looks at three more aspects of the DHC’s decision: the limits of the dynamic effect principle in infringement suits, the use of forum non conveniens as a check against tenuous jurisdictional claims, and the extent to which courts should look beyond the pleadings when applying the doctrine of demurrer. She explains how these raise interesting questions about the balance between preventing forum shopping and ensuring that genuine claims are not shut out at the threshold.

SpicyIP Tidbit: Kriti-cal Plating: Delhi HC Finally Signals Sorting the Personality Rights Salad Platter

In Kriti Sanon v. BBE Marketing Inc., the Delhi High Court’s ad interim order offers a welcome departure from the increasingly expansive approach to personality rights injunctions. By distinguishing between the different interests and causes of action that tend to be bundled under the label of “personality rights”, the Court sets out a more measured framework for assessing such claims. Dr. Aakanksha Kumar examines what the order gets right, where it leaves some questions unanswered, and what we can expect at the next hearing.

Other IP Developments

The Consumer Standard of Deceptive Similarity: Questions Unanswered by the Sai Silks Judgement

The Telangana High Court’s recent observations in Sai Silks v. SKP B Gopinath have questioned whether the traditional standard of a consumer with “average intelligence and imperfect recollection” remains relevant in contemporary trademark disputes, and whether it is due for a revision. But does greater consumer awareness justify replacing this standard, or does it risk shifting the burden of avoiding confusion from traders to consumers? Adyasha Syam examines the judgment’s doctrinal inconsistencies and considers whether the existing test needs reform or simply a more context-specific application.

[Part II] RAM, Routine, and Rights: Looking at the IP Chapter in the EU-India Draft FTA

Continuing the discussion on the India-EU FTA, in Part II of her post, Maneesha Gupta examines how the proposed distribution and making-available rights could conflict with TRAI’s existing non-discrimination requirements and blur the regulatory distinction between traditional broadcasters and OTT platforms, with potentially significant consequences for competition, consumer choice, and India’s policy space.

Call for Submissions: Innovation Brief Invites Blog Posts on IP, Technology & Competition Law (Deadline: 30th November, 2026)

The Innovation Brief, NLU Delhi, is inviting blog post submissions on IP, Technology & Competition Law. The last date to share submissions is November 30, 2026. Interested readers can read the call for submissions.

Case Summaries

Amazon Seller Services Private Limited v. State of Karnataka on November 4, 2026 (Karnataka High Court)

Image from here

The Karnataka High Court dismissed Amazon’s petition under Section 528 BNSS to quash an FIR registered under Sections 51(1)(b) and 63 of the Copyright Act on a complaint by the daughter and publisher of the late author Ravi Belagere, over a pirated Kannada book sold on Amazon, Flipkart and Meesho at ₹149 against an MRP of ₹350. Amazon argued that it is only a marketplace intermediary, entitled to safe harbour under Section 79 of the IT Act and the 2021 Intermediary Rules, and that it neither sells nor lists the book. The State and the complainant said the due-diligence compliance is disputed, noting that Amazon’s own records showed about 6,719 copies sold in 2019 against only 3,000 printed by the copyright holder. The Court observed that the front and back covers of the sold book differed from the original though the contents were the same, and that the investigation was at a nascent stage. It found that the question of due diligence involves seriously disputed facts. It held that quashing at the investigation stage is rarely warranted and that the Court cannot conduct a mini-trial. The petition was rejected, and Amazon was given liberty to approach the appropriate forum at the appropriate stage.

Mr. Gautam Kumar Biswas v. M/S Doctor Biswas Ayurveda International Private Limited and Others on November 3, 2026 (Delhi High Court)

The Delhi High Court heard a petition under Section 50 of the Copyright Act, 1957 seeking rectification of the Register of Copyrights by expunging a registration for the artistic work “GOOD HEALTH AYURVEDA”. The petitioner’s senior counsel submitted that, under the proviso to Section 45(1), an application to register an artistic work capable of being used in relation to goods or services must be accompanied by a Trade Marks Registry certificate that no identical or deceptively similar trademark has been registered or applied for by anyone other than the applicant. He pointed to a search report filed by the respondent showing several identical “Good Health” marks, registered or pending. Despite this, the Registry issued a certificate on November 5, 2025 recording that no such marks exist except the applicant’s own. When confronted with this, counsel for the Registrar of Copyrights said she would seek instructions. The Court passed no ruling, listing the matter on November 26, 2026.

Manash Lifestyle Private Limited v. Sh. Mayur Dhanji Hanat and Others on November 2, 2026 (Delhi High Court)

The Delhi High Court granted an ex parte ad interim injunction in a suit by Manash Lifestyle Private Limited, which operates the beauty store Purplle, for infringement of its registered trademark “ALPS GOODNESS”, its copyright and trade dress, and passing off. The plaintiff stated that the defendants were selling counterfeit “ALPS GOODNESS ROSEMARY WATER” through genuine listings on Amazon. It relied on test purchases showing counterfeit packaging with minor errors, and on a leaflet presenting a “BUFF OUT” product as the “NEW LOOK” of its product. The Court was prima facie satisfied that the defendants were selling counterfeit products using identical trademarks, copyright and trade dress, and found the balance of convenience in the plaintiff’s favour. The defendants were restrained from using the mark, packaging and leaflet. Amazon was directed to delist the counterfeit offers, without removing genuine listings, and to disclose the sellers’ GST and KYC details within two weeks. The plaintiff was exempted from pre-litigation mediation.

Mahashian Di Hatti Private Limited v. Ashok Kumar and Others on November 5, 2026 (Delhi High Court)

Image from here

The Delhi High Court granted an ex parte ad interim injunction in a suit by Mahashian Di Hatti Private Limited (MDH) against John Doe operators of websites, domain names and email IDs that falsely offered MDH dealerships, distributorships and franchises. The plaintiff, whose “MDH” mark is on the Trade Marks Registry’s well-known list, stated that these sites used its mark and its registered Kirti Nagar address to look authorised and to induce prospective dealers to invest money. The Court was prima facie satisfied that the defendants had infringed the plaintiff’s intellectual property and would mislead the public, finding the balance of convenience in the plaintiff’s favour. The defendants were restrained from using the mark and from passing off as connected with the plaintiff. The domain name registrars (GoDaddy, Hostinger and Hosting Concepts) were directed to lock and disable the domains and email IDs within 72 hours and disclose KYC and BSI details. The DoT, NIXI and MeitY were asked to issue notifications to ensure compliance. The plaintiff was exempted from pre-litigation mediation, and was given liberty to implead further websites before the Joint Registrar.

The Aryan Educational Society v. Aaryan International School on November 3, 2026 (Delhi High Court)

The Delhi High Court dismissed the defendant’s applications under Order IX Rule 13 CPC to set aside an ex parte decree of 25 October 2024 and under Section 5 of the Limitation Act to condone a 196-day delay. The decree restrained the defendant school from using “Aaryan International School” as infringing the plaintiff’s “The Aryan School” marks and awarded damages and costs of ₹5,00,000. The defendant said it learnt of the decree only on 14 February 2025 and blamed its advocate for not appearing and keeping it informed. The Court found no vakalatnama, letter of engagement or correspondence to establish that the advocate was engaged. It held that, even if he was, nothing showed the alleged negligence. The defendant admitted service of summons and did not claim insufficient time to appear. It was implausible that a large institution would not follow up for over seven months, when orders and case status are on the Court’s website. The Court held that a litigant must be vigilant and cannot shift all blame to counsel, and found no sufficient cause, dismissing the applications.

Modi-Mundipharma Pvt. Ltd. v. Arlak Biotech Private Limited and Another on November 4, 2026 (Delhi High Court)

The Delhi High Court granted summary judgment under Order XIII-A CPC and decreed a suit by Modi-Mundipharma against the makers of nitroglycerin controlled release tablets sold as “Z-CONTIN”. The plaintiff owns “NITROCONTIN” in Class 5 and over 80 registrations in the “CONTIN” series of marks, together with claims of copyright in its label and trade dress. It also alleged that the defendants’ product copied its formulation, its “controlled release tablets” wording and its pink-and-white colour scheme. One of the defendants was said to be a habitual infringer already injuncted in another suit. The defendants did not appear despite service. Their right to file a written statement was closed on 10 April 2026, and they were proceeded against ex parte on 12 August 2026. The Court found that allowing “Z-CONTIN” would likely cause confusion about association with the plaintiff, and that the plaint averments stood uncontroverted. It thus held the plaintiff entitled to summary judgment. The suit was decreed in terms of prayers 62(i) to (v), with nominal damages of ₹2,00,000 and costs.

Finecure Pharmaceuticals Limited v. Mr Nilesh Jain and Others on November 5, 2026 (Delhi High Court)

The Delhi High Court granted an ex parte ad interim injunction in a copyright suit by Finecure Pharmaceuticals over the contents and design of its website, http://www.finecurepharma.com. The plaintiff alleged that the defendants’ website, cubitlifesciences.com, reproduced its text, product photographs, packaging artwork, layout and design, and adopted its tagline “Making Lives Healthier”. It also alleged that the defendants presented its corporate particulars, awards and credentials as their own. The plaintiff relied on a copyright registration, and on an assignment letter from the agency that built the website. The Court found, on the registration, the assignment and a comparison of the two websites, a prima facie case of infringement, with balance of convenience and irreparable injury in the plaintiff’s favour. The Court restrained the defendants from uploading, reproducing or communicating the plaintiff’s copyrighted works, including the content, layout and look and feel of its website. It granted exemption from pre-institution mediation and issued summons and notice.

Goldmedal Electricals Pvt. Ltd. v. Bashir Ahmed Bhat trading as M/S R and B Electricals on November 5, 2026 (Delhi High Court)

The Delhi High Court granted an ex parte ad interim injunction against a Srinagar-based trader using “GREAT MEDAL” on electrical goods, in a suit by Goldmedal Electricals for passing off and copyright infringement. The plaintiff, through its predecessor, has used “GOLDMEDAL” since 1979, with registrations dating from 17 February 1986, and holds copyright in its logo. The defendant holds a Class 11 registration obtained on a “proposed to be used” basis. His Class 9 application for wires and cables was abandoned in the plaintiff’s opposition, and the plaintiff has filed a cancellation petition against the Class 11 registration. The Court found the marks structurally and phonetically similar, since “MEDAL” is retained and “GOLD” is replaced by “GREAT”, and the adoption prima facie dishonest. It held that the defendant has no statutory right in Class 9, and that his Class 11 registration does not bar a passing-off action under Section 27(2) of the Trade Marks Act. The Court granted the injunction because electrical goods affect public safety. The defendant was restrained from dealing in electrical goods, including LED lamps, fans, wires and cables, under the mark.

CMYK Printech Limited v. Ascendas Media Private Limited on November 5, 2026 (Delhi High Court)

The Delhi High Court granted an ex parte ad interim injunction restraining a former franchisee from publishing the Hyderabad edition of the English daily “The Pioneer” after its MoU was terminated. The plaintiff has used the mark since 1865 through its predecessors. Its earlier registrations expired on 28 November 2021, with renewal or restoration pending, and several fresh applications are pending. The defendant’s right to publish stemmed from a 19 June 2018 MoU, which the plaintiff terminated on 16 February 2026 for unpaid dues. The plaintiff stated that the defendant kept publishing despite a legal notice and an assurance to stop, and that six months from service of the termination notice ended on 17 August 2026. The Court held, prima facie, that the long use showed goodwill even though the earlier registrations had lapsed. It found that the defendant’s right to use the mark depended on the MoU, so its publication under the mark could not be justified, and that the editorial content was beyond the plaintiff’s control. The balance of convenience favoured the plaintiff, and the injury to its goodwill could not be compensated in damages. The defendant was restrained from using, publishing or circulating “The Pioneer” in print or digital form, or from passing off.

M/s Amala Earth Private Limited v. The Registrar of Trade Marks on November 3, 2026 (Delhi High Court)

The Delhi High Court allowed an appeal under Section 91 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, against the Registrar’s order of 1 January 2025 refusing an application for the label mark “O.N.E” in Class 5. The Registrar refused it under Section 11(1) as similar to earlier marks, without dealing with the appellant’s reply to the Examination Report. The reply had stated that the appellant’s other registrations in several classes, the use of the mark since 10 August 2023, and the dots between “O”, “N” and “E” distinguish it. It also explained that “ONE” is an acronym for “Organic, Natural and Earth Friendly Living” and differs from the cited “ONE” and “ONE SPORTS NUTRITION”. The Court held that merely reciting the language of Section 11(1), without addressing these grounds, does not make a speaking order. It observed that a quasi-judicial authority must record reasons and at least apply its mind to the reply. The Court set the order aside and remanded the application to the Registrar for fresh decision within six weeks, expressing no view on the merits.

B. Karthiyani and Another v. Novex Communications Pvt. Ltd. and Another on November 5, 2026 (Madras High Court)

Image from here

The Madras High Court granted an ad interim injunction to a couple against Novex Communications, which had threatened copyright action over music at their wedding cocktail event and dinner. The couple, who are marrying on 15 November 2026 at Taj Connemara, Chennai, sought a declaration that Novex’s threat is groundless, and an injunction restraining it from disturbing the event. They stated that they hold a No Objection Certificate from IPRS dated 20 October 2026, and that Novex’s 27 October 2026 communication to the hotel demanded consent and a fee for playing any sound recordings. Their counsel relied on the Explanation to Section 52(1)(za), under which “religious ceremony” includes a marriage procession and other social festivities associated with a marriage. The Court did not decide the larger questions, observing that they can be tested later and that Novex’s own notice acknowledges the position on Section 52(1)(za) as under judicial scrutiny. It held that the couple had made out a prima facie case with the balance of convenience in their favour, and that Novex can be compensated in money if it ultimately succeeds. Novex was restrained from disturbing the event or entering or lingering near the venue.

Helsinn Healthcare SA and Another v. Intas Pharmaceutical Limited on November 10, 2026 (Delhi High Court)

The Delhi High Court granted an ad interim injunction in a patent suit by Helsinn Healthcare SA and its exclusive licensee against Intas, restraining its “NO-CINV” product. The suit patent was granted on 23 March 2023 and is valid until 18 November 2030. It covers an oral dosage form of netupitant and palonosetron for chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting, and the plaintiffs sell it as “AKYNZEO”. Intas launched NO-CINV, a combipack of netupitant 300 mg and palonosetron 0.5 mg, on 7 November 2026, and the plaintiffs sued within two days. The Court found infringement prima facie evident and uncontested, relying on the reasoning in Helsinn v. Hetero, where a combipack was held to be an integrated combination. Intas argued that combining two known substances lacks novelty, but admitted that it had filed no proceedings to challenge validity. The Court held that it had not “cleared the way” and had taken a calculated commercial risk. The defendant has been restrained until the next hearing, and must file its reply by 17 November 2026 with invoices and stock details. The Court noted that its observations are prima facie.

Other IP Developments

International IP Developments

Thanks to Adyasha Syam for the case summaries.

Read More